T-196: de Winter reports three smaller rational upper bounds at 227, 229 and 260
V3 C3 Upper bound confirmed superseded by T-225
Three complete rational source certificates report finite upper-bound improvements at the exact sides they state: ; ; .
The three certificates and their duplicate-square and outside-container controls were decided here on 20 October 2026 by both maintained exact routes, and the frozen comparison rebuilt; no route here is the source's code, so the replay is independently re-implemented. The 20 October review decided all three again on a third exact route of its own, refused sharp controls 1e-30 past contact on both maintained routes, and found no blocking defect.
Issue 668 reports the three exact rational certificate sides on 17 October; the retained licensed successor changes only LICENSE and the root README. The ledger preserves this report before Couzo issue 672 and Daniel issue 674 at overlapping counts. No arrangement identity, local minimum or optimum is established.
Significance, composition and next rung
- Significance
- Two case ceilings move, by 7.27e-03 at 227 and 1.11e-02 at 260, the first improvement at 260 below 11 + 4*sqrt(2), in a construction family that Couzo and Daniel improved further within three days; no lower bound or optimum.
- Next rung
- None for the bound. V4 and C4 need a second accepted adversarial review by a distinct reviewer and a retained human oversight record; one AI review, of 20 October, is retained.
- Novelty
- previously-published Present in an identified source
The cases
As published
Proven
- exact
Citation record n-227
lowerKarakuş 2026, arXiv corrects Nagamochi 2005 (confirmed T-083)
upperde Winter et al., GitHub (confirmed T-225)
Open
- optimality
The case record
As published
Proven
- exact
Citation record n-229
lowerKarakuş 2026, arXiv corrects Nagamochi 2005 (confirmed T-083)
upperDaniel 2026, GitHub (confirmed T-225)
Open
- optimality
The case record
Proven
- exact
Citation record n-260
lowerKarakuş 2026, arXiv corrects Nagamochi 2005 (confirmed T-083)
upperCouzo & Daniel, GitHub (confirmed T-225)
Open
- optimality
The case record
Results on these cases
12 results in the register on , oldest first, each with what it established and how it stands now.
2005 published T-007 ·
for
V0 C1 Lower bound incomplete on these cases, superseded by T-083
2026-09-04 published T-085 ·
Nagamochi 2005, Lemma 1 is false for every container with and
V3 C3 Correction confirmed
Karakuş; Vlasenko · Karakuş 2026 · chelokot Nagamochi counterexample 2026 · packet · register
2026-09-29 published T-083 ·
for every nonsquare
V3 C3 Lower bound confirmed
Karakuş · Karakuş 2026 · source · register
2026-10-05 published T-101 ·
Exact certificates of 77 catalogue packings:
s(n) ≤ S',1.2e-16to9.8e-15above each sideV3 C3 Upper bound confirmed on these cases, superseded by T-225
Daniel after Couzo, de Winter, Ellsworth, Levy · evand exact optima 2026-10-05 · packet · register
2026-10-12 established T-155 ·
Exact regularized sides at 59 counts,
5.4e-20to9.9e-15below the ceilings they replaceV3 C3 Upper bound confirmed on these cases, superseded by T-225
2026-10-13 published T-180 ·
Closed-form lower bound for every non-square , reported
V0 C1 Lower bound reviewed on these cases, superseded by T-083
Hosono · wand125 closed form 2026-10-14 · packet · packet · register
2026-10-17 published T-196 this result ·
de Winter reports three smaller rational upper bounds at 227, 229 and 260
V3 C3 Upper bound confirmed superseded by T-225
de Winter after Levy · de Winter upper bounds 2026-10-17 · packet · register
2026-10-17 published T-198 ·
Daniel's opening n229 dilation certificate, after Couzo and de Winter
V3 C3 Upper bound confirmed superseded by T-225
Daniel after Couzo, de Winter, Levy · Daniel n229 dilation 2026-10-17 · packet · register
2026-10-17 published T-227 ·
Couzo's refinements of de Winter's 227 and 229, below T-196 at both
V0 C0 Upper bound recorded superseded by T-225
Couzo after de Winter, Daniel, Levy · Couzo issue 672 2026-10-17 · packet · packet · register
2026-10-18 published T-199 ·
Daniel's smaller n229 update, replacing the opening certificate
V3 C3 Upper bound confirmed superseded by T-225
Daniel after Couzo, de Winter, Levy · Daniel n229 dilation update 2026-10-18 · packet · register
2026-10-18 published T-223 ·
Couzo's smaller packings at 204 and 260, the two in the corpus of issue 678's 85 bounds
V3 C3 Upper bound confirmed superseded by T-225
Couzo after de Winter, Polkovskyi, Daniel, Fang, PingYou Ltd, Levy · Couzo issue 678 2026-10-18 · packet · register
2026-10-20 published T-225 ·
Daniel's solved, regularized views at 204, 227, 229 and 260, each the smallest side reported there
V3 C3 Upper bound confirmed
Daniel after Couzo, de Winter, Polkovskyi, Levy · Daniel regularized lists 2026-10-20 · packet · register
Links
- On this site
- Case record, · Frontier row, · Case record, · Frontier row, · Case record, · Frontier row, · T-196 in the results table
On GitHub, at main
- Register
- T-196 in
results.yaml, line 27528 - Evidence
E-de-winter-668-upper-report·E-de-winter-668-upper-exact-feasibility- Proofs and certificates
- certificate
source - Sources
- de Winter upper bounds 2026-10-17 (its own site, retained copy)
- Source packet
resources/web/de-winter-upper-bounds-227-229-260-2026-10-17/README.md- Artifacts
12 artifacts and controls
resources/web/de-winter-upper-bounds-227-229-260-2026-10-17/README.mdresources/web/de-winter-upper-bounds-227-229-260-2026-10-17/source/n227/n227_exact.json.gzresources/web/de-winter-upper-bounds-227-229-260-2026-10-17/source/n229/n229_exact.json.gzresources/web/de-winter-upper-bounds-227-229-260-2026-10-17/source/n260/n260_exact.json.gzresources/web/de-winter-upper-bounds-227-229-260-2026-10-17/acquisition/claims.jsonresources/web/de-winter-upper-bounds-227-229-260-2026-10-17/receipts/exact-certification.json.xzresources/web/de-winter-upper-bounds-227-229-260-2026-10-17/review/review-2026-10-20/README.mdcampaign/issue-intake/upper-bounds-20261018/README.mddocs/project/reviews/review-2026-10-20-de-winter-668-upper-bounds.mdtests/test_upper_bound_reports.pytests/test_upper_bound_reports_668.pytests/test_evand_arrangement_reports.py- Case file
frontier/n-227.md(verified lower, verified upper, reported lower, reported upper) ·frontier/n-229.md(verified lower, verified upper, reported lower, reported upper) ·frontier/n-260.md(verified lower, verified upper, reported lower, reported upper)