As published
= corrects Nagamochi 2005open
Proven
- exact
Citation record n-183
lowerKarakuş 2026, arXiv corrects Nagamochi 2005 (confirmed T-083)
upperDaniel 2026, GitHub (confirmed T-220)
Open
- optimality
Bounds
13.99958017…
13.9995801787362526- Found by
- Daniel 2026
- Construction
- —
- Source
- [Daniel n183 subgrid 2026-10-19]
- Evidence
E-evand-680-n183-report
13.99958017…
13.9995801787362526The reported value, verified here.
13.61383353…
13.613833531794- Proved by
- Hosono 2026
- Kind
- counting
- Scope
- Unrestricted unit-square packing with independent rotations and disjoint interiors.
- Note
- Hosono's closed form (wand125, 13 October 2026, T-180): >= a(N) for every non-square N >= 49, from a measure of line segments on 34 intervals of the fractional part. At , k = 13 and interval 28 give a(183) = 13.613833531794956650722991072135..., here rounded down at 12 and 30 places. The source replayed its certificate with its own checker; no replay has run here.
- Source
- [wand125 closed form 2026-10-14]
- Evidence
E-wand125-closed-form-report
13.54798835…
13.5479883506- Corrects
- Nagamochi 2005 (T-007)
- Evidence
E-karakus-strip-lower,E-karakus-strip-measure-interval
0.45159182…
Verified upper minus verified lower.
Results in the register
T-007 V0 C1 Nagamochi · 2026-08-31 · 321 cases
for
T-083 V3 C3 Karakuş · 2026-10-02 · 301 cases
for every nonsquare
T-085 V3 C3 Karakuş; Vlasenko · 2026-10-02 · 315 cases
Nagamochi 2005, Lemma 1 is false for every container with and
T-124 V0 C0 Daniel after Couzo · 2026-10-07 · 178 cases
Reported non-strict local minima for 178 source configurations
T-180 V0 C1 Hosono · 2026-10-14 · 264 cases
Closed-form lower bound for every non-square , reported
T-220 V3 C3 Daniel after Couzo; register seed data from Levy · 2026-10-19 · n = 183
Daniel's finite sub-grid upper bound for 183 squares, after Couzo's n182 packing
Claim and records
- Claim
- = 13.999580178736252502081470897571 < 14, from the original rational certificate, printed safely upward as 13.999580178737. Independently re-verified here by the project's maintained exact geometry implementations relative to the producer's code, with complete all-pair/wall coverage and duplicate-square/outside-container controls. Credit Daniel after Couzo's n182 packing, through an explorer descendant, insertion, crossovers and refinement; crossover mates were not logged. The regularized display file is retained source history, unexecuted here.
- Significance
- A complete rational certificate gives a sub-grid packing at n183, about 4.20e-4 below the retained side-14 grid. Full exact primary replay and the accepted independent mathematical review support this finite case result; no optimality or public priority is claimed. The review endorses S3.
- Novelty
- previously-published Present in an identified source
- Records
upper: replayed here; lower: external proof (read here), audited here
formal lower differs from report
not rigid, numerically checked, numerical multiprecision
Evidence: E-translation-escape-not-rigid
Scope
Square 0 of the retained witness (witness id 1) translates 0.191447 along (-1, 0) with the packing still valid, so the configuration admits a non-trivial feasible motion; 28 of its 183 squares do. Every constraint is exactly affine in the slide parameter, so the arithmetic carries no linearization error, but the coordinates are the witness's own finite-precision transcription: this settles the retained configuration, not the true optimum. Rigidity and optimality are independent, and this bears only on the former.
Regularized by the Squares Project with Daniel's regularizer (evand/square-packing, MIT), with the project's modifications: same-side exact re-solve (devtools.regularize_same_side). A drawing of T-220's packing at the witness's own side: a pure regularization, which proves no new bound, so not a result.
- Priority: Earlier house 14.0 from [Kingbird], the case’s ceiling until 19 October 2026; its certificate and replay remain retained.
9 evidence entries
E-kingbird-grid-completeness, E-nagamochi-lower, E-basic-grid-upper, E-karakus-strip-lower, E-karakus-strip-measure-interval, E-nagamochi-lemma1-counterexample, E-wand125-closed-form-report, E-evand-680-n183-report, E-evand-680-n183-primary-exact-feasibility
- [Kingbird] record catalogue
- [Nagamochi 2005] lower bound proof
- [Friedman DS7] survey
- [Karakuş 2026] lower bound proof
- [wand125 closed form 2026-10-14] lower bound proof
- [Daniel n183 subgrid 2026-10-19] upper bound report
— open
Hosono’s closed form, 14 October 2026. Hosono’s closed form (wand125, 13 October 2026, T-180) states for every non-square , from a measure of line segments on 34 intervals of the fractional part. At , and interval 28 give , so the reported lower bound here is now , rounded down, above Nagamochi’s closed form, . The source replayed its certificate with its own checker; no record of it has been replayed here, so the verified lower bound is unchanged. The source states that its search, certificates, checkers and text were produced with AI assistance (Claude and Codex), under the direction of and reviewed by Hosono.
House adoption, 19 October 2026. Daniel’s basin-explorer packing after Couzo’s n = 182 packing (T-220) is now this case’s house: its exact certificate proves , the reported and the verified upper bound, rounded outward from its exact side. The exact certificate side improves the previous verified exact side by about . The earlier ceiling, displayed outward as from the trivial grid, applied until this adoption and stays retained as history (the certificate).
Original certificate registered, 19 October 2026. Daniel’s original rational
certificate (T-220) has exact side , which issue
680 prints upward as . Its finite feasibility was independently
re-verified by this project’s two maintained exact geometry implementations, with
complete pair and wall coverage and both invalid controls refused, and accepted in the
separately prompted mathematical review.
The routes share parsing, half-angle conversion, Fraction, runtime and the
separating-axis theorem; they establish neither a clean room nor author or model
diversity. The source’s same-side regularized certificate is retained but was not
executed here, and neither its identity with this packing nor a path between them is
confirmed. The adoption above made the original certificate this case’s house the same
day, and its regularization is recorded with the atlas’s regularized views.
Open. Daniel’s packing (T-220) gives , and the strongest lower bound independently verified here is from Karakuş’s general theorem, leaving a gap of . Until 19 October 2026 the trivial grid gave the ceiling, . General bound: .
The packing
The record catalogue does not picture . Until 19 October 2026 this case’s house was the trivial grid. The house is now Daniel’s original certificate, whose witness the atlas draws (the certificate).
The lower bound
The strongest lower bound independently verified in this record is Karakuş’s general bound, which applies to every nonsquare :
Correction, 2 October 2026. Until that date the verified lower bound here was Nagamochi’s general closed form, , which is stronger at this and is now recorded as a reported bound. Its published proof rests on Nagamochi’s Lemma 1, which Karakuş showed false; nothing is disproved, and no packing beating it is known (review of 2 October 2026). This register had recorded that proof as verified, its own error, logged as defect D-516.
Source-reported bounds are recorded separately from this independently verified theorem.
Verification Code
The programs behind this case’s verified bounds, by their evidence.
The code column says how the code that ran stands to the code its producer used.
VERIFIERS.md says what each program is and whose it is.
| bound | evidence | run | code | programs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| verified lower | E-karakus-strip-lower |
a published proof | no code | no verification code |
| verified lower | E-karakus-strip-measure-interval |
audited here | independent | V-check-karakus-strip-measure (first-party) |
| verified upper | E-evand-680-n183-primary-exact-feasibility |
replayed here | independent | V-sqpack-verify, V-check-rational-witness-independent (first-party); V-upper-bound-reports, V-evand-arrangement-receipts, V-evand-exact-certificates, V-acquire-source (first-party, premises) |
Evan Daniel’s certificate (T-220)
Daniel’s basin-explorer packing after Couzo’s n = 182 packing, reported on jlevy/squares#680, at exact side , displayed upward as (T-220). The certificate gives a rational side and, for each of the 183 unit squares, a rational centre and the tangent of its half-angle; the retained packet holds it with the complete native jobs that decided it.
Both maintained exact routes decided it here, sqpack’s exact separating-axis verifier
and the independent rational corner checker, with its duplicate-square and
outside-container controls; no third exact route has decided it.
No route here is the source’s code, so the replay is independently re-implemented.
The
review of 19 October 2026
accepted the replay for finite feasibility.
That proves , the verified upper bound: confirmed,
independently re-implemented.
It says nothing about optimality, rigidity or a local minimum.
The source’s credits say its work was produced by Claude (Anthropic) under human direction, and the commit that publishes the certificate names Claude Opus 5.5 as co-author.
The author asks that the start be credited to Couzo’s n = 182 packing, this register’s witness of the time, and it is: his basin explorer ran 17 moves at n = 182 from that witness to a packing that was no record, a square was inserted into it, and a tilt-angle swap, two two-parent crossovers and refinement led to this certificate. The crossovers’ second parents, other packings of the same run, were not logged, so that lineage is the author’s account and is not measured here. The source’s 27 numerical candidate flat modes concern the 182-square force-bearing subsystem, excluding a free rattler, and prove no local optimality.
The house it replaces, from the trivial grid, stays retained with its own replay as history.